Purchasing your first home shouldn't feel like rocket science. But without the right guidance, first-time home buyers can make costly mistakes, like failing to take advantage of first-time home buyer programs and loans (opens in a new tab).
Let’s cut through the confusion and discuss some practical tips for making smart choices and saving money when purchasing your first home.
Find Your New Home With The Young Team.
Working with an agent takes the stress out of buying a home. Schedule your consultation today and experience a hassle-free home-buying process with the best real estate team in Ohio.
Get Started (opens in a new tab)
Quick Home Buyer Checklist—Save This!
- Get mortgage preapproval BEFORE house-hunting
- Figure out how much house you can afford based on your debt-to-income ratio
- Don't empty your emergency fund for a down payment
- Shop at least three different mortgage lenders to compare interest rates
- Check your credit report and improve your score for better loan terms
- Budget for closing costs (3%–4% of home price)
- Consider different loan programs (conventional loans, FHA loans)
- NEVER skip the home inspection
- Research neighborhoods at different times of day
- Keep your monthly mortgage payment below 25% of your take-home pay
Buying More House Than You Can Afford
You should prepare financially for buying your first home (opens in a new tab) before you even look at houses. Add up your income, bills, and monthly debt payments. Calculate your debt-to-income ratio—lenders typically want this below 43%. This shows how much house you can afford without stretching your budget too thin.
Get mortgage preapproval from a mortgage lender. This does two things: it shows you exactly how much you can borrow and makes sellers take your offers seriously. Use a mortgage calculator (opens in a new tab) to see what your monthly mortgage payments might be with different down payment amounts.
Different mortgages have different rules. Some help first-time home buyers with lower income or less-than-perfect credit. Don't simply accept the biggest home loan you qualify for. This misstep is how people end up house-poor with no money left for anything else after making their monthly mortgage payment.
Thinking You Need a 20% Down Payment
One common misconception is that you need to put down 20% to buy a house. Not true! Most first-time homebuyers put down about 8%, and some loans let you put down as little as 3%.
The average down payment in Ohio (opens in a new tab) is around $19,000. With Ohio’s median home price of $250,000, that average down payment would be around 7.6%. However, if you’re looking at homes in Cleveland (opens in a new tab), where average prices hover around $125,000, putting $19,000 down would be a 15% down payment. This larger percentage will lower your mortgage payment significantly.
Loved ones can give you money to help with the down payment. Just make sure they know the rules about gift funds. Your lender will tell you how to document this properly during the final loan approval process.
A smaller down payment means higher monthly mortgage payments and usually requires private mortgage insurance (PMI). However, mortgage insurance can be worth the cost to get into a home sooner rather than later.
You can buy a house with no money down in Ohio (opens in a new tab) and elsewhere in the US. Veterans Affairs (VA) loans work for veterans, and USDA loans work in certain areas. The Federal Housing Administration offers FHA loans with down payments as low as 3.5% for buyers with credit scores of 580 or higher. Don't let the down payment myth trick you into thinking renting is cheaper than buying (opens in a new tab).
Missing Out on Free Money for First-Time Buyers
There's literally free money available for first-time home buyers (opens in a new tab)! Many cities and states offer down payment assistance programs that can offer thousands toward your home purchase.
These loan programs aren't just for low-income buyers. Even middle-income households often qualify through the National Association of Realtors' affiliated programs and lenders.
Many programs will even give you grants that you don't have to pay back! Others offer forgivable loans that disappear after you live in the home for a few years.
Your real estate agent or lender should know about these programs from the Federal Housing Administration and other sources. If they don't, find a real estate agent who does! A good agent helps you navigate these options to save money on your first home.
Ignoring Your Credit Before House Hunting
Your credit score directly affects your mortgage interest rates. A better score means getting a lower interest rate (opens in a new tab), which saves you thousands on your loan.
Check your credit report from all three bureaus before talking to lenders. Look for mistakes and get them fixed right away. Even minute errors can hurt your score and affect your home loan options.
Keep your existing credit accounts open—closing accounts can hurt your score. Pay down credit card balances to below 30% of your limits. This improves your score faster than almost anything else.
Don't apply for new credit while house hunting. Each application typically drops your score a few points, which could push you into a higher interest rate bracket and cost you money.
If you have bad credit (opens in a new tab), it may be smarter to take 6–12 months to improve it before applying for a loan. The tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars you save in interest will thank you.
Not Shopping Around for Lenders
Talking to just one lender is a BIG mistake! Get quotes from at least three different mortgage lenders and compare mortgage interest rates carefully.
Getting one more quote saves borrowers an average of $1,500 over the life of their loan. Five quotes could save you thousands more! This is one of the easiest ways to save money on your home purchase.
Don't just compare interest rates. Look at fees, points, and the overall loan terms. Sometimes, a conventional loan with a slightly higher rate but lower fees costs less in the long run than a Federal Housing Administration loan (opens in a new tab). (Long-term mortgage insurance adds up!)
Local banks, credit unions, and online lenders offer different loan programs. A broker can help you shop for financing, but it is wise to browse on your own to ensure you're getting a good deal. The time you spend comparing lenders will pay off with lower mortgage payments for years to come.
Oh, and don't worry about the credit hits from all those credit checks. The big credit bureaus like it when you're being smart about getting a big loan. As long as you make all your inquiries within a 45-day window, it's all recorded as one credit check.
Not Budgeting for Closing Costs
Don’t be surprised when you’re closing on your first home (opens in a new tab): closing costs are unexpected for many first-time buyers. Typically, these extra fees run at 3%–6% of your home's price. On a $300,000 house, that's $9,000–$12,000!
These costs include:
- Loan origination fees
- Title insurance
- Property taxes
- Home Insurance
- Inspection fees
Don't forget to budget for moving expenses and initial repairs. Even "move-in ready" homes often need some work.
You can ask the seller to pay some closing costs, but this works better in buyer's markets. In competitive markets, sellers might reject offers that ask for closing cost help.
Skipping The Home Inspection
Skipping a home inspection to make your offer more attractive is like buying a used car without looking under the hood—a huge mistake! It's even more of a mistake if you're buying the home online (opens in a new tab) and won't be able to look around it yourself.
A good home inspection (opens in a new tab) finds problems you can't see during a showing, such as foundation issues, bad wiring, plumbing problems, and roof damage, which can cost thousands to fix.
Use inspection results to negotiate. Ask the seller to make repairs or lower the price to cover the costs.
For older homes, consider specialized inspections for mold, pests, or sewer lines. These cost extra but can save you from expensive surprises later.
Not Having an Emergency Fund After Buying
Emptying your savings for a down payment leaves you vulnerable if something breaks or you lose your job.
Keep at least 3 months of expenses in your emergency fund after closing. This protects you from foreclosure if something goes wrong.
If putting 20% down would drain your savings, consider a smaller down payment. Yes, you'll pay PMI, but that's better than having no financial cushion.
First-time homebuyers face higher foreclosure risks than repeat buyers. An emergency fund is your best protection.
Letting Your Bank Decide Your Budget
Just because you qualify for a big loan doesn't mean you should take it! Lenders look at your gross income, not your take-home pay or other expenses, when calculating how much house you can afford. For most first-time buyers, the goal is to buy a starter home (opens in a new tab), not necessarily a forever home.
Keep your monthly mortgage payment below 25% of your take-home pay. This leaves room for savings, fun, and unexpected expenses. Many home buyers regret stretching their budget too thin and ending up with uncomfortably high monthly debt payments.
Remember that homeownership comes with extra costs: repairs, maintenance, and higher utility bills. These expenses can eat into your monthly budget fast. Your debt-to-income ratio might look fine on paper, but it can feel very different when you're living with those payments every month.
Think about your future plans as well. If you’re thinking of expanding your household, changing careers, or wanting to travel, a smaller mortgage gives you more flexibility. Being house-poor is no way to live—luxury homes (opens in a new tab) are appealing, but they’re probably not the best choice for first-time buyers.
Not Getting Mortgage Preapproval Before House Hunting
House hunting without mortgage preapproval wastes your time and sets you up for disappointment. You might fall in love with homes you can't afford when you haven't figured out how much house you can actually buy.
Mortgage preapproval gives you a clear budget and shows sellers you're serious about your home purchase. In seller's markets (opens in a new tab), most homeowners won't even consider offers without preapproval letters. It's a critical step toward final loan approval.
The preapproval process also uncovers any credit report problems early. This gives you time to fix issues before finding your dream home. During this process, review your debt-to-income ratio, existing credit accounts, and employment history.
Getting preapproved takes just a few days and costs nothing with most lenders. Given the fairly lengthy timeline of the home-buying process (opens in a new tab), anything that can expedite things is recommended.
There's no good reason to skip this step! It's the smart way to start your home-buying journey.
Picking the Wrong Real Estate Agent for You
Don't just work with the first agent you meet. Interview at least three before you decide to work with one.
A good agent knows your target neighborhoods inside and out. They’ll spot problems you may miss and guide you to areas that fit your lifestyle.
Finding the right realtor as a first-time home buyer (opens in a new tab) is key. Ask how many first-time buyers they've helped recently. Experience with first-timers matters. First-time homebuyers have unique needs and opportunities (like local first-time buyer programs) and generally benefit from more guidance.
Check their reviews online and ask for references. Great agents have happy past clients who love to recommend them.
Not Researching Different Loan Programs
Conventional loans aren't your only option! Explore these loan programs:
FHA loans from the Federal Housing Administration need a 3.5% down payment and work with lower credit scores (opens in a new tab) (as low as 580). They're perfect for many first-time home buyers, though they require mortgage insurance for the life of the loan in most cases.
VA loans through Veterans Affairs offer 100% financing for veterans and active-duty military. They often have lower interest rates and no mortgage insurance requirement.
USDA loans also offer 100% financing for homes in rural and some suburban areas. If you're open to living in one of Ohio’s charming small towns (opens in a new tab), check if you qualify for this program.
State and local programs often have special loans for first-time buyers with competitive mortgage interest rates and down payment assistance. A good real estate agent can connect you with local resources for these programs.
Falling in Love With a House Too Quickly
Emotional decisions lead to financial regrets. Make a list of your must-haves and nice-to-haves before you start looking.
Stick to your budget even when you find a house that seems perfect. Being house-poor ruins the joy of homeownership.
Be ready to walk away if the inspection reveals serious problems or if the seller won't negotiate fairly.
Remember: there will always be another house. Patience saves you from costly mistakes.
Not Budgeting for Ongoing Homeowner Costs
Your monthly mortgage payment is just the beginning. Homeownership comes with many extra costs that first-time home buyers often overlook:
Property taxes and insurance add hundreds to your monthly housing costs. These often rise over time and are sometimes included in your mortgage payments (opens in a new tab).
Budget about 1%–3% of your home's value for annual maintenance and repairs. That's $3,000–$9,000 per year on a $300,000 home! It helps to create a home maintenance checklist (opens in a new tab), complete with approximate costs, because this is money you need to save beyond your regular monthly mortgage payment.
Utility bills usually run higher in a house than in an apartment. Ask to see the seller's typical monthly costs before buying to avoid surprises that strain your budget.
HOA fees in some communities add $200–$400 monthly to your housing costs. Ensure that you understand what these cover and factor them into your debt-to-income ratio calculations.
Not Planning for Moving and Initial Home Expenses
Many buyers focus so much on the down payment that they forget other upfront costs.
Moving expenses add up quickly. Even local moves often cost $1,000 or more if you hire professionals.
New homes often need immediate updates: paint, carpet cleaning, appliances, or basic repairs.
You may need temporary housing if your closing dates don't line up perfectly. Budget for this possibility, and be prepared to handle the logistics of this temporary relocation.
Stock your new home with essential supplies: tools, lawn equipment, cleaning supplies, and more.
Forgetting About Seller Concessions
Don't be shy about asking sellers to help with costs. They can pay for needed repairs or contribute to your closing costs. Closing costs in Ohio (opens in a new tab) range from 2%–5%, so having the seller contribute can make a big difference.
Use inspection results as leverage. If the home needs work, request either repairs or a price reduction.
In buyer's markets, asking for 3%–6% of the purchase price in concessions is common. In competitive markets, you may need to limit requests to major issues.
Your agent should help you decide what concessions to ask for based on market conditions and the condition of the home.
Not Researching Neighborhoods as Carefully as Houses
The perfect house in the wrong neighborhood quickly loses its charm. Smart home buyers research these factors before making an offer:
Educational access and options affect your daily life even if you don't have children. Popular and accessible schools help homes hold their value better. This is true whether you use the schools or not.
Visit at different times of the day. That quiet street might be a traffic nightmare during rush hour. The peaceful area you saw on Sunday might be very different on a weekday, even in popular suburbs (opens in a new tab)!
Check neighborhood data and talk to potential neighbors about the area. First-hand information is invaluable when deciding where to buy a home.
Look at future development plans. New shopping centers or highways can dramatically change a neighborhood and affect your home's value.
Consider your commute carefully. A long drive might seem manageable at first, but it can become a huge quality-of-life issue over time. Many home buyers regret prioritizing a bigger house over a shorter commute.
Look Before You Leap, First-Time Homebuyers
Buying your first home is exciting, but don't let emotion override common sense. Take your time, do your research to make sure it's the best time for you to buy a home (opens in a new tab), and don't skip important steps like inspections or comparing mortgage interest rates from different lenders.
Remember that patience pays off for home buyers. It’s better to wait a few months for the right house at the right price than to rush into a decision you'll regret for years. Use the tools in this guide to help navigate your first purchase. Before you know it, you’ll wake up every morning in your new home, happy that you didn’t make costly mistakes that other first-time buyers have made.
Buy a Home With Confidence.
Partner With The Young Team.
From your first home to your forever home, let the Young Team handle it all. Contact us now to schedule a consultation and take the first step towards buying your dream house in Ohio.


